Imperfect Market Structure

In the second half of this segment, examine three other market structures, particularly monopoly, oligopoly and monopolistic competition prepared by our JC Economics Tutor Simon Ng from Economicsfocus. For oligopolisitc competition, it is important to distinguish between collusive and non-collusive markets based on the analysis of real-world examples, like the smartphones industry and oil cartels, like the OPEC.

economics tuition notes definition

Definition

What is an imperfect market structure?

-In the imperfect market structure, there is imperfect market information and immobility of factors of production. The number of firms ranges from few to many and the product can be heterogeneous or homogeneous. There is slight to great market control as firms can create their own market share.

What is a Monopoly?

-In the monopoly form of market structure, there is imperfect market information and mobility of factors of production. There is only one firm and the product is homogeneous. The firm has strong market control as it can impose strong barriers to entry, either naturally or artificially. The firm in this industry is price-setter whereby the firm can set the price or the quantity level.

What is an Oligopoly?

-In the oligopolistic form of market structure, there is imperfect market information and mobility of factors of production. There are a few firms and the product is differentiated. The firms have strong market power as they can create barriers-to-entry but the firms are mutually interdependent. The firm in this industry is price-setter whereby the firm can set the price or the quantity level.

What is Monopolistic Competition?

-In the monopolistic form of market structure, there is imperfect market information and mobility of factors of production. There are many firms and the product is highly differentiated. The firm also possesses slight market power as it can create its own market share through product differentiation but the control of the market is limited. The firm in this industry is price-setter whereby the firm can set the price or the quantity level but has a high degree of substitution, contributing to the presence of a price-elastic demand curve.

What are the characteristics of a monopoly?

- Single producer

- No close substitutes for the product

- Imperfect knowledge of product

- High barriers to entry What are the characteristics of an oligopolistic firm? -small numbers of large firms relative to market size

- Products can be homogeneous or differentiated -imperfect knowledge

- Existence of substantial barriers to entry

What are the characteristics of a monopolistic competitive firm?

-large numbers of buyers and sellers

-differentiated products

-no/low barriers to entry

-imperfect knowledge




What profits can be reaped by a monopoly in the short run?

-Supernormal profit

What profits can be reaped in an oligopoly short run?

-Supernormal profit


What profits can be reaped in a monopolistic competition short run?

-Supernormal profit


Why firms in monopolistic competition will reap normal profit in long run?

-Firms in monopolistic competition reap supernormal profits in the short run. Due to low barriers to entry, more firms enter the industry to reap the supernormal profits. Assuming total market demand for the product remains the same, the entry of new firms will cause demand for each firm to fall. At the same time demand also becomes more price elastic. Hence firms in monopolistic competition can only reap normal profit in the long run.


What profits can be reaped by a monopoly in the long run?

-Supernormal profits

What profits can be reaped in an oligopoly long run?

-Supernormal or normal profits


What profits can be reaped in a monopolistic competition long run?

-Normal profits


What is market power?

-Market power refers to the ability to set price or output and to price discriminate


Explain how market power affects the price and output level.

-The greater market power a firm has, the greater its ability to set price or output level.


Explain how market power affects the production equilibrium.

-The greater the market power a firm has, the greater its ability to produce at a higher output level


What are barriers to entry?

-They are conditions that prevent or impede the entry of new firms into an industry. These barriers can limit the amount of competition faced by existing firms in the industry.


What are artificial barriers to entry?

-Artificial barriers to entry are those set up by the firms to prevent entry of new firms. Eg legal barriers like patent rights, collusion/mergers, non-price competition like product differentiation


What are natural barriers to entry?

-They are natural conditions that prevent a firm from entering the industry. Eg significant cost reduction arising from economies of large scale production, control over supplies of input

What barriers of entry can the firms in monopolistic competition has?

-Artificial barriers to entry set up through aggressive advertising and product differentiation.

What are the types of non-price competition?

-product differentiation

-advertising

-research and development

-branding

What is product differentiation?

-It involves making artificial changes to a product in order to make it seem different or special as compared to the competitor’s goods. One example would be difference in packaging.

What is a kinked-demand curve?

- This model explains why once a price-output combination has been decided upon and the oligopolistic firms will not want to experiment with further price changes.


Why is there a kinked-demand curve?

-When the firm increases price, the rival firm will not increase price as the rival firm can gain as the customers will switch the consumption from the firm to the rival firm. This will lead to a large reduction in quantity demanded since the degree of substitution is large, contributing to the demand curve for this portion to be price-elastic. However, when the firm decreases the price, the rival firms will follow suit as they will lose out if the customers of the rival firms may switch the demand to the firm. This means a smaller degree of substitution which will lead to a less than proportional increase in quantity demanded, contributing to the demand curve for this portion to be price-inelastic. It also implies that there is price rigidity as the firm is unlikely to change price as there is little to gain from price changes unless there is large percentage change in cost condition. This reflects that there is high degree of mutual interdependency which contributes to the condition of price rigidity.


What is allocative efficiency?

-Allocative efficiency is a type of economic efficiency in which economy/producers produce only those types of goods and services that are more desirable in the society and also in high demand. Allocative efficiency is a point where marginal benefit is equal to marginal cost (MB=MC)

What is production efficiency?

-Productive efficiency occurs when the economy is utilizing all of its resources efficiently. The concept is illustrated on a production possibility curve where all points on the curve are points of maximum productive efficiency.


What are the aims of firms?

-Main aims of firms will be to maximize profits and reduce costs


What is x-inefficiency?

-X-inefficiency is the difference between efficient behavior of businesses assumed or implied by economic theory and their observed behavior in practice caused by a lack of competitive pressure.


It occurs when a firm has little incentive to control costs, causing the average cost of production to be higher than necessary.


Why are imperfect market structures unable to attain allocative efficiency in the short run?

-The firms will not be able to attain allocative efficiency as the firms focuses on profit maximization in which production level is at where the marginal cost is equal to the marginal revenue. This is below the social efficiency level of production, in which the production level is at where price is equal to marginal cost. This is so as the downward sloping demand curve due to the market power of the firms will contribute to the difference of the production in the SR.


Why are imperfect market structures unable to attain production efficiency in the short run?

-The firms are unlikely to produce at the optimal capacity of production where the average cost of production is lowest as the firms are usually producing at the excess capacity of production.

Why are firms profit-motivated?

-Firms are profit-motivated as it is financially advantageous. Additional profits can serve as a reward to business owners or employees, redirected into further investments to boost earnings or paid out as dividends to investors.


What is profit maximization?

-Profit maximization is the process by which firms determine the price and output level which brings in the greatest profits. Profit maximization occurs when MC=MR with MC rising (on the graph).


What is cost minimization?

-All firms will try to minimize costs in order to maximize profits. Cost minimization occurs when the firm find means to cut down on overhead and variable costs.


What is two-tier charge?

-Two tier charge refers to charging the same good or service two different prices to two different group of consumers.

What is marginal cost (MC) pricing?

-MC pricing is a price regulation method at which the government requires monopolies to set price at marginal costs.

What is a natural monopoly?

-A natural monopoly is a condition of an industry whereby it is most efficient (involving the lowest long-run average cost) for production to be concentrated in a single firm.

Why does natural monopoly exist?

-Capital intensive industries, like the utilities industries, have huge overhead costs and hence set the condition for natural monopoly to exist so as to prevent expensive duplication of services.


What is the most common market structure?

-Monopolist competition

What is the most inefficient market structure?

-Monopoly


How should the government regulate monopolies?

-MC pricing

-Two tier charge

-taxes

-licensing and quotas


Under what circumstances should the government regulate monopolies?

-Where there is market dominance, firms have the capacity to distort the market price and quantity to their advantage. When there is market distortion which results in deadweight loss and unequal distribution of income, the government should regulate monopolies.


What is consumer exploitation?

-Firms with market power can distort the market price and fix high prices which result in unequal distribution of income between consumers and producers, hence resulting in consumer exploitation.


What is nationalization?

-It refers to the public ownership of the entire industry.

What is legalization?

-It is the process of removing a legal prohibition or regulation against something which is currently not legal.


What is price regulation?

-Price regulation refers to government intervention in monopoly price when there is market distortion of prices. This is to ensure that there is allocative efficiency and equal distribution of income between producers and consumers.

What is perfect mobility of factors of production?

-Perfect mobility refers to the efficient ability to move factors of production - labor, capital or land - out of one production process into another.


How does a perfect competitive firm attain production equilibrium? How does the firms in perfect competition set price and output level?

-Allocative and production efficiency can be attained at production equilibrium based on profit maximisation, where MC=MR.


-Price and output levels are set by the industry, through market forces of demand and supply and the firm will abide to the price level.


How does a monopoly attain production equilibrium? How does the monopoly set price and output level?

-Under this market structure, the marginal revenue and average revenue is downward sloping from left to the right due to the market power and thus, allowing it to exercise as a price setter while the marginal cost will rise as there is over-utilization of fixed capacity of production. As a profit maximizing firm, it will produce at the level of output where the marginal revenue is equal to the marginal curve.


-Monopolies have strong market control as it can impose strong barriers to entry, either naturally or artificially. The firm in this industry is price-setter whereby the firm can set the price or the quantity level.


How does an oligopolistic firm attain production equilibrium? How does the firms in oligopoly set price and output level?

-Under this market structure, the marginal revenue and average revenue is downward sloping from left to the right as it can exercise as a price setter due to the market power while the marginal cost is rising due to over-utilization of fixed capacity of production in short run. Additionally, the MR and AR is  kinked with the portion being price-elastic when price and the portion being price-inelastic when price. As a profit maximizing firm, it will attain production equilibrium, where the marginal revenue is equal to the marginal cost.


-Oligopolies have strong market power as they can create barriers-to-entry but they are mutually interdependent. The firm in this industry is price-setter whereby the firm can set the price or the quantity level.


How does a monopolistic competitive firm attain production equilibrium? Q. How does the firms in monopolistic competition set price and output level?

-Under this market structure, the marginal revenue and average revenue is downward sloping from left to the right as it can exercise as a price setter due to the market power while the marginal cost rises due to over-utilization of fixed capacity of production in short run. As a profit maximizing firm, it will attain production equilibrium at the level of output where the marginal revenue is equal to the marginal curve.


-Monopolistic competitive firms possess slight market power as it can create its own market share through product differentiation but the control of the market is limited. The firm in this industry is price-setter whereby the firm can set the price or the quantity level but has a high degree of substitution, contributing to the presence of a price-elastic demand curve.

What is cost condition?

-Cost condition refers to the level of cost of production which will affect the pricing and output decisions of a firm.

What are the impacts of licensing on the society?

-Licensing raises the cost condition of the licensees, hence lowering their competitive advantage as compared to the licensor. The licensor gains market power and sets output and price level at production equilibrium at MC=MR. However, this is not equal to production at P=MC or min AC which promotes allocative and production inefficiency. Therefore, the society suffers from a welfare loss which is the value of deadweight loss.


-However, licensing also increases competition as it allows new firms to enter the market which is otherwise impossible due to intellectual property right. Competition can drive prices down as well as raising the quality of product for the society.



What are the impacts of intellectual property right on the society?

-Intellectual property rights create market power of the firm, seen in terms of downward-sloping MR and AR. Production equilibrium at MC=MR will not be equal to production at P=MC or min AC as the production is at the excess capacity. As a result, allocative and production inefficiencies arise. Consequently, there will be welfare loss in which is the value of deadweight loss in the society.


i. Allocative inefficiency (DWL)

ii. Higher price and lower quantity (consumer exploitation)

iii. No production efficiency but AC can be lowered due to dynamic efficiency (R&D)

iv. Provide incentive for R&D/profit - more fund for R&D

v. May raise welfare for the society - huge positive externalities